Replies to This Forum

Permalink Reply by Apurba Jyoti Majumder on April 23, 2014 at 16:38

Yes

Fine may be more than the cost of the book.

Actually if a user keeping a book with him/her for 3 years, then it must be a very important book and consequently he is not allowing other readers to read the book.

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Govind Prasad Sharma on April 24, 2014 at 0:30

I think the maximum fine should be the double of the cost of book.

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Siddhartha Shankar Ray on April 27, 2014 at 20:30

Dear Sri karak,

Thanks for the post. As I understand, you have opened the Pandora's Box in this forum &  exposed the true face of a section of Teachers (in a school in this particular case!) 

Being the General Secretary of Teachers' Association what is your response to such activities??

Mathematically speaking, with a fine @Re1/- per day, Rs. 2660/- constitutes more than SEVEN YEARS!!  I wonder what the concerned people had been doing for such long time!

As I understand, if this is the case, the forum members will certainly agree with me that no amount of self defense can ever justify such activities.All I can say that if a person can deprive all other users and retain a library book for so many years, s/he should be taken into tusk in hardest way.

I have no idea about the book borrowed,(like type of the book and number of copies acquired by the Library etc.)  but as I understand from my experience it is too long a period. The argument of slapping fine of three times or four times of the cost of the book is immaterial. The nonchalant outlook of the person who can deprive all other users and more importantly, can ignore all norms of Library ( may be the library has purchased multiple copies of the book and a person has retained a single copy of the book in his/her custody  while other copies are used by library members)

I am sorry to say that as I understand, it is not an isolated incident,in a school, rather, a common practice of Teachers in many academic institutions like Colleges &/or Universities often retain books for several years depriving students over the years. I was away from office for several weeks during last couple of months and traveled extensively in suburban & rural Bengal and visited several libraries and observed several such cases. The administrative authorities, (Principals/Registrars, Academic Councils etc.) often remain mum about such incidents and the Librarians (especially in Schools & Colleges) being miniscule in number and lower in estimation (simply; because the institutions are completely dominated by teaching fraternity!!) never dare to take any action nor there is any directive to take any befitting action by library personnel against such people. If the Audit party can remain strict in their stance with such exemplary punishment ( I am perturbed to use the word punishment but could not found a befitting alternative!!)

Sincerely,

Siddhartha S. Ray, Calcutta

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Raja Manikyam on April 28, 2014 at 20:25

In our library our practice is as below

We will send five reminder to the user if the user is not responded after the five reminders library should consider the book as lost and 3 times price of book will be collected from the user.

• ▶ Reply