Replies to This Forum

Permalink Reply by Subrata Singha on September 25, 2012 at 22:55

I totally agree Merit needs to be the prime yardstick in any selection also NET.

 

 

 

Permalink Reply by Manmeet Kaur on September 25, 2012 at 23:36

Good effort

Permalink Reply by AISWARIA SATHEESH on September 26, 2012 at 6:26

sir, I agree with u because of not only I belongs to general category. the problems raised by u were in my mind too for last some days.but I didn't know how to react against this . I had noticed that some people wishes u for qualifying in the next exam.but all had forgotten to tell about the age limit.for qualifying JRF age limit is only 28 for general category. what should we do if we get ony limited chances and tuff criteria for qualifying NET? How will we react against this ill practice of UGC.Now a days the living status of all middle class people were same with out any concession whether they belongs to general, SC/st, or OBC.So the sufferings for study as well as living were also same. But when we came to schools, colleges or any institutions for study or job these reservation categories were getting maximum scholarships, fee concession etc.That we can accept with open mind besides our feelings.But why this mark criteria being different only because of  being in a general category.From this we can think that the government itself strive for creating an ineqality among its citizen by caste,caste creed etc.if u agree with me please reply and what should we do against this ?

Permalink Reply by thirupathi jayasri reddy on September 26, 2012 at 6:26

you are right, this must be discussed.

Permalink Reply by Ashok Mistry on September 26, 2012 at 18:25

I,d like to thank to all for your valuable comments in this forum.All of you are highly qualified.All of you are right at your side.I agree that in this economic condition reserve should be made on the basis of economic status of a family.Because I found that a lot of reserve category people belongs to the upper strata of the society and enjoying all reserve category facilities but actually they don't need it.Besides a number of general category family are suffering a lot to maintain their family.The policy-makers of India felt further to uplift those general category. Thus the OBC Category created excluding the CREAMY LAYER people. But among those sc/st category creamy layer cannot be excluded because of political issue but I personally feel it should be done .

One example:- Suppose you are the parents of four child.Will it be possible that all child should be in same merit level? never.As a parent you should pay a little extra attention to the low meritorious child because you love all four child.India is our mother land and all the post-independence policy-makers treated the Indians as their child.If they had narrow-minded,we never called M.K.Gandhi, THE FATHER OF INDIAN NATION.Please explain the following issues.

1. Whether all the UGC recruited reserve category teachers are of low quality??????
2.  If UGC set  65% qualifying marks for all.What happened? You the non-qualified people be passed? Only a few number of  reserve people be passed covering this benchmark because I got 63% belong to reserve category and a lot of reserve category people covered 65% benchmark. So please don't be jealous to them.
3. All of us can remember that  what is happening to the HORIZON (lower category) people till the day.
4. Even lower category people are not permitted to enter in the temple.

Do you feel that you don't need to save them? Whether they are getting the equality Mr.Hitendrasinh????

Whether they don't have the right to enter in The School????????????????

Permalink Reply by Digambar Bhaurao Waghmare on September 26, 2012 at 20:32

yes sir you are right
I strongly agree with you
only net exam failed so all are carrying
anybody thinking about backward caste person life from freedom to till date

Permalink Reply by Hitendrasinh Trikamsinh Desai on September 26, 2012 at 21:18

I never against  the process of uplift the SC /ST/OBC  . when they apply for NET they want only 50% in pg subject but open category  student wants 55%  . At this level  they got there special category fever from UGC  and any one can agree with this this is process of uplift them . But the passing level should  be same for all .

please give me example if any other eligibility  exam have different  passing  level in india ?

you say for  lower category people are not permitted to enter in the temple if ti is true than they have to fight for there right and we all support  them . I think you want to divert the real issue .

My only Issue is that     UGC Have different eligibility criteria for passing NET Exam ?  is  this  criteria make injustice for general category  student's  ?  

Dear friends  I want say  sorry  for all if anyone hurt with my this topic  . But  this is hard reality  of GENERAL  CATEGORY STUDENT'S .

THANK you  Mr Ashok  Mistry  for sagging  me for going  Court .i definitely  think on it .

you have to  remember that reservation is not permanent  provision.  when it started  our father  of  nation is against  it .According to him all Indian's  are  equal .

 

HITENDRASINH  DESAI

Permalink Reply by Ashok Mistry on September 26, 2012 at 21:39

Sir,There are some links which will help to know more about dalit.  and they are not permitted to enter in the temple.

http://www.telugupeople.com/videos/video.asp?id=108017

http://gaddeswarup.blogspot.in/2008/10/dalit-shot-for-entering-temp...

http://www.thehindu.com/news/states/tamil-nadu/article2615879.ece

http://www.freetv9.com/?p=37609

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dalit

Permalink Reply by Anasua Ghosh on September 26, 2012 at 21:03

Dear Mr. Ashok, It seems that with time you have become meritorious and intelligent enough to call others as "You the non-qualified people " "jealous of you "  etc.. These type of comments is not expected from a person securing 63% in NET. Qualifying NET is not the end of the world. Anyways congrats for your success.

         It seems that you are not living in 21st century, may be residing some centuries ago, where you are talking about people not allowing others to enter schools, temples etc. In todays world these things rarely happen not even in very interior rural areas. And these things have nothing to do with the discussion.

             Reservation system was introduced mainly to abolish poverty, to provide SC/ST/OBCs  with free knowledge, economic help, resources of daily life etc. free of cost which is being provided to the SC/ST/OBCs from centuries ago and no body has no objection against it.  These things were not equally distributed in our society in early times and Government took this step to bring equality . But "brain" has been distributed equally among all of us. Merit is developed by hard work and proper utilisation of brain. When SC/ST/OBCs are provided with all social and economic help, free education , everything free of cost where is the need to still provide them reservation in qualifying exams and jobs? There should not be any reservation in qualifying exams and securing jobs. Merit should be properly judged, specially in exams like NET/SET, Medical exams, civil services etc. the qualifiers are which are building block of our nation.

But as I said that Reservation system is incurable in India because people have and are enjoying the sweet taste of Reservation and will continue to enjoy it for the sake of their own interest.

Permalink Reply by Ashok Mistry on September 26, 2012 at 21:17

Ms.Anusua please go through the news.

http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2003/06/0602_030602_untouch...

There are a lots of news you can find madam

Permalink Reply by Prachi on September 26, 2012 at 22:28

very true 

Permalink Reply by Digambar Bhaurao Waghmare on September 26, 2012 at 22:32

TO Anasua Ghosh
I said that Reservation system is incurable in India because people have and are enjoying the sweet taste of Reservation and will continue to enjoy it for the sake of their own interest
I think you should taking some taste I pray To God in text time you may born in SC caste family
Thanks & Regards
Digambar B Waghmare

• ‹ Previous
• 1
• …
• 5
• 6
• 7
• 8
• Next ›
• Page